I guess someone heard me repeatedly whining about Seattle's lack of summer. We've had a string of beautiful, summery weather this week and last. So I feel that sharing an ice cream recipe with you is completely appropriate now.
I like to create recipes that can support substitutes, in part because our tastes here vary, and also because food intolerances can be a bit of a moving target. I've updated this ice cream recipe I to use coconut cream versus coconut milk for its fat content and more consistent results.
For the sweetener, you can substitute maple syrup with honey, but other sweeteners may require a different amount. I encourage you to experiment while you're heating up this mixture. Add the sweetener slowly and taste along the way. That way you'll find what works for you.
As for the peanut butter, good substitutes are almond butter, or to get away from nuts completely, try a seed butter such as sunflower seed butter, which is made from sunflower seeds.
Vijay says
Tried it today and it came out very well.
Used the following ingredients (ratio as mentioned in the recipe)
- store bought Coconut milk in tetra pack (Dabur)
- Peanut butter (Sundrop)
- Refined Sugar
- Baking Choclate powder (weikfield)
- Coconut oil (Parachute)
- pinch of salt
All ingredients available in Chennai. Didn't have vanilla so skipped it, didn't want to use any animal product so skipped the honey. couldn't feel the smell/taste of coconut oil & peanut butter. It was so creamy, couldn't believe it doesn't have milk. Should try using cashew instead of peanut butter next time. Also I'd prefer a bit more bitterness in chocolate ice-cream, should try adding a little bit of coffee.
Thanks a lot. Its a keeper !!
Megan Baker says
Wondered if it was possible to just make the chocolate coconut ice cream and not add the peanut butter mixture. My son needs chocolate Coconut ice cream for his school country project. I made your original recipe with the pb and it was delicious. I'm hoping I can simply eliminate the pb mixture and still have a great tasting ice cream. What do you think?
Thanks!
Erica says
Yes, definitely.
Caiti Jayne says
I made this with grass fed whole milk and butter, used 1/4 cup white sugar instead of 1/2 cup honey and 1/2 cup cocoa powder istead of 1/4 cup, and for the first time i experienced SUCCESSFUL ice cream! I know, I know, white sugar...but i have tried to use my new ice cream maker (xmas gift) twice this year and neither of the recipes worked. I was tired of wasting really expensive ingredients only to have to throw it away, so i decided to use organic peanut butter vs almond butter, white sugar instead of honey. BUT, this recipe was perfect, i couldnt believe how amazing the ice cream turned out. just the chocolate part was just like the best store bought ice cream you could get. when i added the peanut butter, unfortunately it sort of mixed into the chocolate and only made very small gobs of peanut butter, very tiny, i was hoping for chunks or strings, but regardless, that can be worked on, it was probably my method that caused it. it still tastes perfect and the texture is amazing. im also amazed i didnt have to use any cream. (our whole milk is 9g fat per 250mL). i will definitely be adapting this ice cream base for all ice creams from here on out. im so glad it finally worked!!!
Karin says
I am trying to make this recipe right now.
I haven't put the mixture into my ice cream maker yet.
While trying to cool it off though in preparation for doing so, the coconut oil is solidifying and floating to the surface.
What did I do wrong?
How do I keep it incorporated??
Thanks!
Erica says
I haven't made this ice cream this season, so this is from memory: I do remember some of it separating and I blended it back in. If it's not blending well, I would strain it out with a slotted spoon and then finish it in the ice cream maker.
Erica says
Update: I've switched to using just a few brands of coconut cream instead of coconut milk. Not all brands are alike. See my recipe notes for the brands I prefer.
Sharon Urlacher says
So, this looks like it could be made without the nut-butter part if you want just chocolate?
Erica says
yes
Ashlee says
Instead of making it the long way by freezing and blending could you put it in a container surrounded by ice and salt then shake it for a while?
Erica says
I don't know but it sounds interesting 🙂
Rebecca says
I made this today and it was the consistency of a slushy at the end... that doesn't seem right. It's a new ice cream maker- Cuisinart 2 Qt- and I doubled the recipe. I put the ice cream slushy in the freezer so hopefully once it freezes it will be thick and non-icy, but any tips off-hand? (btw, the taste is GREAT!)
Erica says
Yes, it will be better once frozen, probably not as smooth though. Sounds there wasn't much fat/oil in the mixture. Icy means more water than fat/oi.
Erica says
Update: I've switched to using just a few brands of coconut cream instead of coconut milk. Not all brands are alike. See my recipe notes for the brands I prefer. I think this should solve the slushy issue.
venus says
OMG...peanut butter chocolate ice cream is myyyyy favorite!!!!! i seriously cant wait to try this. im bummed i dont have a ice cream maker, how many times does it usually take in the blender??? aside from the cocoa, this is scd legal right?
Erica says
It takes about an hour - blending about 3-4 times, from my memory. Place it in the freezer over the course of an hour or so for slushy ice cream. It helps if the ice cream mixture is very cold to begin with and the container is very cold. You can leave the blender container in the freezer before you even start. And, yeah, cocoa is not SCD legal (https://www.breakingtheviciouscycle.info/legal/legal_illegal_a-c.htm)
Eileen says
What ice cream maker do you recommend? I want one for christmas but want to make sure to get a good one that doesn't cost too much.
Jerry says
I always got room for jello, especially ice cream 🙂 This chocolate peanut butter ice cream looks divine.
Brigitte says
Hi there!!!
Loved this recipe....
We had no power due to Hurricane Irene here on Long Island, New York soooo, we used the ice cream ball to make our ice cream...it was "amazin"....
The children we had staying over had a blast I might add
Thank you,
Brigitte
Erica says
Awesome. Hope all is ok! (that goes for everyone out there on the East Coast)
Comfy Belly on Facebook says
Excellent! I've been eating it all week.
Nissa Madrigal on Facebook says
Best ice cream recipe! My kiddos and are requesting more 🙂
Tarantula Den on Facebook says
Ohhh tytytytytytytytyty! Comfy Belly we <3 you!!! :'D My dd will be so suprised we can eat this. Also ty for how to make without ice cream machine since we don't have one yet. What is best brand electric one out there I wonder... ~Tarantula lady
Susan says
My son has Crohn's but his doctor said he can have honey sweetened cocoa, but not chocolate, a real break.
Comfy Belly on Facebook says
Ps - this recipe is not SCD legal, unfortunately. Stay tuned though.
Susan says
Thai Kitchen coconut milk has guar gum which is SCD illegal. Trader Joe's carries coconut milk without it.
Erica says
Yes - TJ's is low fat I believe, so add more coconut oil. Also, fyi, chocolate is not SCD legal, so this recipe is really not SCD legal. Sorry 🙁
Comfy Belly on Facebook says
Faith - yes, pretty much all ice cream can be made this way. It's just a bit more time consuming.
Yadsia @ShopCookMake says
The picture alone looks so enticing. I don't like peanut butter, but maybe almond butter would work. Can't wait to try it.
Faith Epp on Facebook says
That's awesome! I will be trying this. Can this method be done w/all ice cream recipes? Thanks.
Comfy Belly on Facebook says
No need. Place the cooled mixture in a blender and blend. Then place in the freezer for 20 minutes, and take it out again, blend and repeat. Once it starts to resemble ice cream, place it in a container in the freezer. That's it!
Faith Epp on Facebook says
Too bad I don't have an ice cream maker anymore - maybe I should get one?
Jennifer & The Unrefined Kitchen says
This sounds fantastic! I just started experimenting with coconut milk ice cream recipes. I love the tip about adding oil. Is the reason you don't add the nutbutter mixture until the end because it won't set up right in the ice cream maker with it in it? Or is it just so it is a more distinct, separate flavor? Thanks!
Erica says
Yes - I add it at the end so it separate well, rather than blending too much with the ice cream. The thinner you make the nut butter mixture, the more it will turn into chips vs chunks. So if you want streams of butter chips, you could add more honey and/or coconut oil.
Sherilyn @ Wholepromise says
Sounds great and far better for you than traditional ice cream... I think I will give this a go with some homemade almond milk.
Lindann England McPheeters on Facebook says
Sounds awesome! can't wait to try. My sister and I were just talking about how much we like this flavor of ice cream!!