• Whoopie Pies

    Whoopie Pies

    A whoopie pie is a great treat for anyone who likes cake and frosting, and portability. These are easy to stash in a lunch bag or wrap up for later. They even taste great right out of the refrigerator. Here are two recipes for the whoopie cake, spiced and chocolate, and two frosting recipes as well – marshmallow and creamy.

    **I’m retesting this recipe because some have had problems with it. Stay tuned**

    Whoopie pies are a New England and Amish tradition, but in all my years growing up on the East Coast and living in the Boston area, I never had one. How could that be? There’s even a Whoopie Pie Festival.

    They remind me a bit of Ring Dings and Twinkies, probably because of the cake and fluffy sweet filling partnership, and because that’s the closest I’ve come to having one. According to the legend, if Amish children had one of these treats in their lunch box, they yelled “whoooooopie.”

    Pies on baking sheet

    This blog entry is created especially for the blog series, Go Ahead Honey, it’s Gluten Free! – and is a momentary break from the Thanksgiving planning list. I admire all the food bloggers who post on a regular basis, especially since I have a challenging time just keeping up with cooking/baking/shopping/work/etc. on a daily basis, let alone offering up great recipes to share on a schedule. And Naomi Devlin’s blog has a soft spot in my heart, partly because I love Maurice Sendak’s work.

    Notes The spiced version is legal for SCDers.Each recipe make about 6 pies.

    Posted in Dairy-Free, Desserts, Gluten-Free, Lactose-Free, Paleo, SCD, Vegetarian  |  44 Comments

    44 Responses to Whoopie Pies

    1. Tracee says:

      These look like they would be great for lunch boxes. I’m always looking for good lunch box recipes.

    2. Hänni says:

      Yum! The marshmallow filling is calling to me.

    3. Lauren says:

      Stunning! I love the flavours in these – they look fantastic =D.

    4. Oh my! I’ve never had a whoopie pie before… must try, but don’t have access to almond flour :o( Maybe use coconut flour? Found you through Elana’s Pantry!

    5. Jenn says:

      Ooooh whoopie pies!!! They look like they came out beautifully!!

    6. Erica says:

      Marillyn – I haven’t tried coconut flour yet, but these were pretty easy to make, so I’m sure it would work in some ratio.

    7. Marissa says:

      Mmmmmmm. Those look delicious! I will have to add them to my “to bake” list 😉

    8. Chelsey says:

      MMMmm, these look awesome. I am so happy to have found your site 🙂 I am going on SCD starting in January, I can’t wait to try your recipes!

    9. Gorgeous! Those certainl make for a comfy belly. 😉 I’ve made whoopie pies before, but I love that you made these using almond flour and honey–much healthier. 🙂

    10. Deb says:

      I just stumbled across your website while researching gluten-free recipes. The woopie pies recipe was the first one I noticed. I love whoopie pies and can’t wait to try these. I haven’t tried any almond flour yet but plan to eventually. I want to be sure that gluten is really my issue. Would this recipe work with any other gluten free flours? (rice flour etc.) Thanks!

    11. Erica says:

      Hi Deb,
      I haven’t tried any other flours yet, but I bet they work – some suggestions, if you’re feeling lucky, are coconut and other nut flours. Quinoa is one I’m curious about but I haven’t tried yet. Let us know if you try any others.

    12. You have no idea how happy I am to find this whoopie pie recipe!!! My husband was researching almond flour recipes and information last night and found your website. When I saw this recipe I KNEW I was going to have make it a priority to read your whole blog! 🙂 My nutritionist has had me on a no gluten, no sugar, low carb diet for six months now and I figured there was no way I’d be able to eat a whoopie pie again!!! YAY!!! I’m going to try substituting vegetable glycerin for the honey, so I hope it works!

    13. Erica says:

      Thanks, Tracy! I’d be really curious to know if the vegetable glycerin works.

    14. Mollie says:

      I LOVE WHOOPIE PIES! I had them as a child from the amish farmer’s market, and found them again as an adult at my Alexandia farmer’s market. Then I found out I had Celiac disease and I was so sad to say goodbye to whoopie pies. I will make these tonight, I’m so excited to eat these again!

    15. Heather says:

      I thought cocoa is SCD illegal…if it’s not I’ll be one happy gal!

    16. Erica says:

      Heather, cocoa is not SCD legal, but the spiced pie is legal. Sorry!!

    17. BARB says:

      Wow, as a child I ate whoopie pies every single day! Back then you could only buy banana or chocolate. What a treat to make your own & have new flavor combinations, thanks!

    18. Joan McConnell says:

      is shortening legal on scd diet

    19. Christina Mckinney says:

      Ok I just made this recipe and it looks NOTHING like yours..lol..my pies where grainy and hard. I use stevia instead of the honey. Could that be the difference? My batter didnt look as moist as yours..HELP!!

    20. Erica says:

      Joan- yes, shortening is legal.

    21. Erica says:

      Christina – so sorry, but yes, this recipe would require something like honey to add moisture and help hold the flour together. I’m not sure how stevia would work exactly, but it sounds like it didn’t work well at all.

    22. elizabeth says:

      Does the Marshmallow filling taste like marshmallow??? is it good??

    23. Erica,
      I thought it was time to post another comment letting you know I finally “mastered” (for my taste) your whoopie pie recipe using vegetable glycerin and liquid stevia!

      For the pies: instead of honey I use 1/3 cup vegetable glycerin, 30 drops of liquid stevia, and 2 tbsp water. Mine come out thicker than what your picture shows, so I just put the creamy vanilla frosting/filling (or peanut butter) on it and eat them one at a time instead of putting two together like a “pie.” It is still possible, however, to make them smaller, and flatten them on the cookie sheet, in order to eat them as pies.

      I tried to make the pies with only vegetable glycerin but, in my opinion, it tastes better with the combination glycerin and stevia.

      For the creamy vanilla frosting/filling I make a big batch using 1 cup Spectrum Organic shortening, 2 tbsp vegetable glycerin, 30 drops liquid stevia, and 1/2 tsp vanilla.

      Thank you so much for giving me a simple recipe to play with and find something so YUMMY!!!

    24. Erica says:

      Tracy – thanks for sharing your results. I’m sure it will help folks who are using those ingredients!

    25. Erica Cronin says:

      I’m wondering if you can use Stevia in the raw as a sub for honey in this recipe and/or the chocolate biscotti recipe’s? I am not able to eat any honey, and would love to make these whoopie pies and the chocolate biscotti.

    26. Judy says:

      I have made this recipe twice now and both times the batter is like soup. Are you sure that it is 2 cups of almond flour to 1 cup of honey? Do you refrigerate the batter before baking? Any advice would be appreciated. I have tried having all ingredients at room temp. – doesn’t make a difference. Thanks

      • Erica says:

        Yes, it is not a stiff batter. If it’s soupy, it should be a very thick soup. I haven’t made these in a while. My memory is that the batter kind of pours out a bit, so you make small circular piles on the baking sheet. If your batter is very soupy, you can try adding a bit more flour (to thicken it up). One other trick is to put the batter in the refrigerator or freezer for several minutes. Or use less honey, of course. Hope that helps.

    27. Sam says:

      Made these, they taste great but absolutely would not come off the Silpat…so another wasted recipe for me. I think it needs some butter/oil etc in the recipe otherwise they totally stick to the pan!?

    28. Danielle R. says:

      I would like to make your sugar cookies and use one of these frosting recipes. I don’t like to use shortening, so I was wondering if I can substitute butter for the vanilla frosting recipe…would it hold up outside the refrigerator?

    29. Danielle R. says:

      Would it be possible to pipe the marshmallow filling in order to decorate cookies?

    30. JESSICA says:

      OMG, I am DYING as I eat these. SOO delicious. Thanks for the recipe!

    31. Pam Newlin says:

      Even though this is an old post of yours, I wanted to stop by to comment anyway. For Valentine’s Day, I wanted to make my kiddos a special treat and decide to pair your chocolate variation of whoopie pies with The Urban Poser’s Strawberry/Raspberry Frosting. The combination was absolutely to die for and a perfect pink treat for V-Day. Thank you so much for providing a recipe I would be proud to serve to anyone, including people without dietary restrictions.

      The Urban Poser’s frosting:

    32. Beth G. says:

      Hi! I was really excited when I found this recipe. I recently got engaged, and my fiancee and I are thinking about having paleo whoopie pies as the dessert. However, we just tried the recipe and the pies baked into a big sheet. Any ideas to what may have gone wrong?

    33. Stephanie says:

      I was wondering if by any chance that either can be made into a vanilla whoopie pie? And i can not wait to try both of these recipes.

    34. Heather says:

      I just have to comment, as to my brother who doesn’t believe anything other than Corn Syrup can be used in order to make Marshmallow, or even corn starch to keep it from sticking to one’s fingers: I laugh in his face as this recipe used Honey to make it sweet, no more than a few TBs, and used vinegar to keep them fluffy,…

      He says I’m the one who reads and believes the 90% bull crap written articles on the internet, but no, he’s the one who believes those 90% bull written articles, there are alternatives to make marshmallows, the industries are just too lazy and too rich to spend the money for the alternatives. Heck, one can even use Gelatin in place of any sweetener.

      And Marshmallows actually started out using the herb: Marshmallow root, hence where the name came from, and if I recall, it was the bases for making the gelatin, but it was used for sore throats. I forget the link I read on about this.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Free recipes & inspiration

  • Recent Comments

  • Sources & tips

  • Measurement equivalents

    1 tablespoon 3 teaspoons
    1/4 cup 4 tablespoons
    1 cup 8 ounces
    1 teaspoon 5 ml
    1 tablespoon 15 ml
  • Ingredient conversions

    almond flour 1/2 cup 48 g
    coconut flour 1/4 cup 26 g
    honey 1/4 cup 85 g
    honey 1 cup 12 ounces
    maple syrup 1/4 cup 81 g
    maple syrup 1/4 cup 59 ml
    butter 1/4 cup 55 g
    butter 1/2 cup 8 tbsp
    cocoa 1/4 cup 22 g
    chocolate chips 1 cup 6 ounces
    chocolate chips 1 cup 160 g
    olive oil 1/4 cup 54 g
    olive oil 1/4 cup 2 ounces
    coconut oil 1/4 cup 52 g
    Parmesan, grated 1/4 cup 20 g
  • Temperature conversions

    Gas Mark Fahrenheit Celsius
      1/4  225  110
      1/2  250  130
        1  275  140
        2  300  150
        3  325  170
        4  350  180
        5  375  190
        6  400  200
        7  425  220
        8  450  230
        9  475  240
  • Cookbooks

    Coconut Flour Cookbook by Erica Kerwien - Comfy Belly
  •  target=
  • Recently